Posts

Showing posts from 2009

Why Novartis Backed Off from Enterprise Software: Lessons in ERP Change & Configuration Management

Implementing an Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) system across global departments promises lower operational costs, streamlined procurement, and real-time visibility. Yet when leadership treats a large-scale ERP rollout purely as an IT installation rather than an organizational transformation, the result is almost always internal friction, stalled workflows, and resistance. The classic case study "Why Novartis Backed Off from Enterprise Software" illustrates a fundamental truth of contemporary project management: the success of any enterprise system rollout is 100% a matter of Change Management and Configuration Management. 1. Why Was Novartis Struggling with Its Requisition-to-Pay Process? Before rolling out its global SAP R/3 upgrade, Novartis lacked a truly integrated requisition-to-pay workflow across its international operations (Overby, 2003, 2004) : High Manual Processing Costs: Existing invoicing procedures were slow, fragmented, and heavily dependent on manual ...

Projectized vs. Matrix Organizational Structure: Solving Staff Motivation and Retention Challenges

Image
When project-driven organizations experience high staff turnover and declining morale, leadership often confronts two interconnected operational symptoms: Poorly motivated project teams. Premature turnover as skilled specialists leave to seek more permanent, stable roles. To diagnose why these issues emerge—and whether structural redesign can resolve them—we need to compare how two core organizational models handle human capital: the Projectized Structure and the Matrix Structure . 1. When Work Is Organized Along Pure "Project" Lines (Projectized Structure) In a pure projectized model, resources are dedicated exclusively to isolated project teams. While this accelerates short-term execution, management research highlights two major structural drawbacks: it "leads to poor coordination" across the wider enterprise and "eliminates in-depth competence and technical specialization" (Duncan, 1979) . From a...

The Ideal Project Manager: Balancing Technical Mastery and Leadership Skills

An ideal project manager is far more than a schedule tracker or report compiler. From a senior architect's perspective on the ground, true project leadership means guiding an initiative seamlessly across every lifecycle phase—from initial design and planning through construction or production, final handover, and post-project evaluation—while harmonizing people, materials, and systems. To deliver consistently in complex environments, an ideal project manager must master two distinct yet inseparable pillars: Technical Skills and Managerial Skills . 1. Technical Skills: The Foundation of Credibility and Problem-Solving Domain expertise is vital to managing any engineering or construction process effectively. Consider what happens when an organization appoints a project manager who lacks practical technical background on a complex build: How can they accurately evaluate team performance or spot early warning signs in technical submittals? Without hands-on technical judgment, a ma...

Choosing an Organizational Structure & TQM Implementation Procedure: Case Study from The Dubai Mall

Image
Originally written in 2009—and later expanded into my Second Edition practitioner book, Strategic Context of Project Management: Aligning Organizational Architecture, Total Quality Management, and Execution in Complex Construction Environments —this two-part case study examines how project parameters dictate organizational design and why Total Quality Management (TQM) initiatives succeed or stall on mega-projects. Part 1: Choosing the Right Organizational Structure An organization chart is far more than a corporate diagram—it is the operating framework governing task distribution, authority relationships, and team integration (McGraw-Hill, 2009) . When designing a project structure, leadership must align the hierarchy with the scope of work, available technical skills, and six critical operational parameters: Project Cost & Capital Control: When strict budget oversight and shared utilization of high-cost equipment are top priorities, the Functional Structure...